Mary Trace is bright, bubbly, and suddenly dunked back into the dating pool in her mid-thirties. When Mary goes on a blind date set up by a friend, her heart drops when she meets the perfectly gorgeous, and extremely well-groomed John Modesto-Whitford. John, desperate not to be anything like his lying snake of a father, prides himself on being honest to a fault. But after an unexpectedly rocky start, will these two stubborn individuals decide to give each other a second chance?